Running a nanny agency that is ticking along is not the same as running one that is growing. Most established agencies have a core of loyal families and a handful of excellent nannies, but enquiries can be patchy, too many families drift off to job boards after a first call, and some placements end sooner than anyone hoped, bringing refunds or replacement work that eats into margins.
Winning more and better work comes down to a few things done consistently: showing families clearly why an agency is worth paying for, handling each enquiry with care and speed, matching well enough that placements last, and staying in touch so each family comes back as their needs change. Being easy to find when parents search, whether on Google or through an AI assistant, ties it all together.
In our 2026 local search research, ChatGPT or Google AI Mode named 48% of businesses in positions 4 to 6 on Google Maps, but only 23% of those in positions 13 to 15: the further down the map, the less often AI recommends you.
This guide is for owners of established nanny, maternity nurse and babysitting agencies in the UK. It does not cover setting up an agency. It focuses on winning the families you want, converting more of them and earning repeat placements and referrals.
Key points
- Families who compare you with job boards need to see the time, judgement and protection your fee buys, written out plainly.
- A fast, structured first consultation and a clear job brief convert more enquiries than a long brochure.
- Good matches and follow-up in the first months reduce failed placements, refunds and replacement work.
- A family’s needs change from maternity care to a permanent nanny, babysitting and holiday cover, so plan for the whole journey.
- Accurate profiles, honest reviews and clear answers to parents’ questions help you appear in local search and AI recommendations.
In this guide
- Know where your best placements come from
- Show families why an agency is worth the fee
- Turn more enquiries into placements
- Match well so placements last
- Plan for the whole family journey
- Look after your nannies as well as your families
- Build partnerships that bring the right families
- Reviews and reputation
- Local search: showing up when families look nearby
- AI search: how assistants choose which agencies to suggest
- Frequently asked questions
- Final thoughts
Know where your best placements come from
Before changing anything, look at the last twelve months of placements and ask three questions for each one: where did the family first hear of you, what type of placement was it, and how much was it worth once any refunds or replacements were taken into account.
Most agencies find a pattern. Referrals from previous families and partners such as antenatal teachers tend to convert well and lead to longer placements. Families who found you through a search often convert well if your website answered their questions. Families who also posted on job boards are often the hardest to convert, because they are still deciding whether they need an agency at all.
| Source | Typical strengths | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Referral from a past family | High trust, quick decisions | Volume depends on staying in touch |
| Partner referral | Often early in pregnancy or a relocation | Partners need regular, useful contact |
| Google search or Maps | Families actively looking now | Needs strong reviews and clear fees |
| AI assistant recommendation | Families with specific questions | Relies on clear, consistent information |
| Job board browsers | Large numbers | Lower conversion and more price comparison |
Use this to decide where to spend your time. If referrals bring your best placements, building those relationships is worth more than another advert.
Show families why an agency is worth the fee
Many families now see childcare apps and job boards as the default and treat an agency fee as optional. You will win more of them by being specific about what they get, rather than saying you are “trusted” or “experienced”.
Spell out the practical value:
- Time saved: you screen applicants and present a shortlist of nannies who meet the brief, rather than a family wading through dozens of responses.
- Judgement: you have interviewed the nanny, spoken to referees and know how they handle situations a family cannot test in one meeting.
- Compliance: you obtain written references and copies of qualifications before introducing anyone, as the Conduct Regulations require for work with children.
- Market knowledge: you know realistic pay rates, hours and expectations in their area and can stop them making an offer that will not hold.
- Support: you help with the contract, trial days and the first weeks, and offer a replacement or refund if a placement ends early, on the terms you publish.
Write these points on your website, include them in your first email to every family and refer to them in conversation. Families are far more likely to pay a fee when they understand what it covers.
Tip
Publish a short “what happens after you call us” timeline, from the first consultation to the nanny’s first day. It reassures anxious parents and sets expectations about how quickly you work.
Turn more enquiries into placements
Parents often contact several agencies on the same evening. The agency that responds quickly, listens well and gives a clear next step usually wins.
The first call
Aim to speak to every new family within a working day. Use a structured consultation to build a job brief:
- The children’s ages, routines and any additional needs.
- Hours, days and start date, including flexibility.
- Live-in or live-out, and whether a nanny share is possible.
- Duties, such as school runs, cooking for the children or light housekeeping.
- The qualities the family values, from experience with twins to a driving licence.
- Pay expectations and whether the family understands gross and net pay.
Talk about pay early
One of the most common causes of friction is confusion between gross and net pay. Some families and nannies still discuss net figures, which can leave a family surprised by the true cost once tax, National Insurance and pension contributions are added. Explain this early, encourage families to agree pay as a gross figure and suggest they use a specialist nanny payroll service. It protects the placement and shows your expertise.
Shortlists and interviews
Present a small number of well-matched candidates rather than a long list. Explain why each one fits the brief, arrange interviews promptly and suggest a paid trial day before an offer is made. Then confirm everything in writing, including your fee, when it is due and your replacement terms.
Match well so placements last
A placement that ends after six weeks costs you goodwill, time and often money. The best way to protect your income is to match well in the first place and support both sides in the early months.
- Check the brief against reality: if a family’s expectations are unrealistic for the pay offered, say so tactfully before you introduce anyone.
- Look beyond experience: consider personality, parenting style, communication preferences and how the nanny and parents will work together.
- Agree the contract and duties early: encourage families to put hours, duties, holiday and pay in a written contract from day one.
- Follow up at set points: contact both the family and the nanny after the first week, the first month and around three months.
- Act early on problems: a mediated conversation about a small issue often saves a placement.
Keep a note of why placements end. If the same reason keeps appearing, such as unclear duties or unrealistic hours, change your consultation process to catch it earlier.
Plan for the whole family journey
The most valuable families are not one-off placements. A family’s needs change over several years, and an agency that stays in touch can help at every stage:
- Pregnancy: a maternity nurse or night nanny, often booked months ahead.
- Return to work: a permanent nanny or nanny share.
- Toddler and pre-school years: babysitting, holiday cover and sickness cover.
- School age: an after-school nanny or part-time role with school runs.
- Another baby: a maternity nurse again, and changes to the nanny’s role.
At each placement, note when the family’s needs are likely to change, and get in touch before they start looking elsewhere. A friendly message when a child is about to start school, asking whether they will need a different arrangement, is often welcome.
Seasonal demand
Demand rises at predictable times: before the new school year, as parental leave ends, ahead of the summer holidays and in the run-up to Christmas and New Year’s Eve for babysitting. Build your candidate pool and contact past families ahead of each peak, rather than when the requests arrive.
Look after your nannies as well as your families
Your candidates are customers too. Good nannies have choices, and they return to agencies that treat them fairly, reply promptly and find them good families.
- Keep in touch with nannies between roles and let them know about suitable jobs first.
- Give honest feedback after interviews, whether they are successful or not.
- Make it clear that registering with you is free for candidates, as agencies generally cannot charge work-seekers for finding them work.
- Ask your best nannies to recommend friends, and thank them when they do.
A strong pool of nannies who trust you is what allows you to say yes quickly to families, especially for urgent cover.
Build partnerships that bring the right families
Some of the best placements come through people who meet families at key moments. Realistic partners for a nanny agency include:
- Antenatal teachers and baby classes: parents start thinking about maternity nurses and childcare during pregnancy.
- Independent schools and nurseries: families often need after-school care or holiday cover.
- Relocation agents and corporate HR teams: families moving to a new area need help quickly and lack local contacts.
- Hotels and event venues: guests and wedding parties often ask for babysitters.
- Family solicitors and accountants: they meet families going through changes that affect childcare.
Offer partners something useful, such as a short guide to employing a nanny or a talk to parents, rather than simply asking for referrals. Keep in touch regularly and thank partners when their referrals lead to placements.
Reviews and reputation
Parents read reviews closely when choosing an agency, and they notice details such as how quickly the agency responded, how well the nanny matched and how problems were handled. Ask families for a review once a placement has settled, usually after the first month or two, and ask nannies for reviews of their experience too.
Reply to every review, thank the reviewer and mention the type of placement without sharing personal details. If you receive a negative review, respond calmly, acknowledge the concern and offer to discuss it privately.
Local search: showing up when families look nearby
Families looking for help typically search for phrases such as “nanny agency near me”, “maternity nurse agency”, “babysitting agency [area]”, “nanny share [area]” or “emergency nanny cover”. Local results matter, because parents want an agency that knows their area and can introduce candidates who live within easy reach.
For an established agency, good local visibility usually means:
- A complete Google Business Profile: an accurate primary category, all the services you offer, the areas you cover, current hours and photos of your team and office.
- Fresh reviews: a steady flow of recent reviews from families and nannies.
- Consistent listings: the same name, address and phone number across recruitment directories, childcare directories and local business listings.
- Service and area pages: pages for maternity nurses, nanny shares, babysitting and each area you cover, explaining how you work there and what families can expect.
- Local links and mentions: coverage on parenting websites, school newsletters and community sites.
Fixes to your profile and listings can help within weeks, and most agencies see clear improvements within two to three months, while those in very competitive areas should expect it to take longer. If you would rather spend your time matching families and nannies, specialists in local SEO for nanny agencies can manage your profile, listings and content.
AI search: how assistants choose which agencies to suggest
More parents now ask AI assistants for help, usually in detailed questions such as “Which nanny agencies near me place maternity nurses?”, “How do nanny shares work and which agencies arrange them?” or “Is it worth using a nanny agency instead of a job board?”. ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode can all give answers like these.
The companies do not publish exactly how their tools decide which businesses to mention. They say their answers draw on information from across the web, and in practice they tend to cite businesses whose details are clear, consistent and supported by reviews and other sources. Good practice for nanny agencies includes:
- State your services and areas plainly, for example “nanny agency placing permanent nannies, nanny shares and maternity nurses across south-west London”.
- Publish your vetting steps, fees and guarantees so assistants can describe them accurately.
- Answer the questions parents ask, such as gross and net pay, nanny shares and trial days, on your website.
- Keep every listing consistent and updated when services or contact details change.
- Earn mentions on reputable sites, such as local parenting publications and partner organisations.
AI answers are not always accurate and can lag behind changes. Check what the main assistants say about your agency every few months and correct the source information if anything is wrong.
Frequently asked questions
How can we compete with childcare apps and job boards on price?
Do not try to match them on price. Explain what your fee covers, including screening, references, matching, contract support and a replacement guarantee, and show it clearly on your website and in your first conversation.
When should we take a registration fee?
Many agencies take a modest fee once the family has agreed the job brief and your terms. It filters out families who are not serious, but explain exactly what it covers and whether it is deducted from the placement fee.
How do we reduce placements that end early?
Spend more time on the initial brief, be honest about unrealistic expectations, encourage written contracts and paid trial days, and follow up with both sides in the first three months.
Should we offer babysitting if we mainly place permanent nannies?
It can bring regular contact with families and lead to future placements, but only if you have a reliable pool of sitters. Start with existing families and expand gradually.
How often should we contact past families?
A few times a year is usually enough, timed around natural changes such as a new baby, a child starting school or the summer holidays. Keep messages helpful rather than sales-focused.
Final thoughts
Growing a nanny agency is about trust at every stage. Show families clearly what your service includes, respond quickly, match carefully, support placements in the early months and stay in touch as each family’s needs change. Combine that with a strong local presence and clear information for search and AI tools, and more of the right families will find you, choose you and come back.